CH₃CH₃

Urban legends

The things everybody has heard about drugs. Each one here has a verdict, the earliest appearance we can document, what the record actually says, and who spread it. A verdict of true is allowed: some of them are right.

1 legend match.

Stimulants

  • False

    Try meth or crack once and you are addicted.

    Most people who try cocaine never become dependent: about one in 16 to 20 do in the first year, about one in five ever. Smoking it raises the risk. The 1986 numbers behind the panic came from a cocaine hotline's callers.

    First documented: , National Drug Enforcement Policy Board report to Congress on crack, citing a cocaine hotline's callers

    Origin, evidence and 9 references

    Origin

    The claim took hold with crack in 1986. That September a federal board reported to Congress on "this inexpensive highly addictive by-product of a readily available illicit stimulant". Its evidence for how fast users got hooked came from a May 1986 survey of callers to a cocaine hotline: 78% "reported the onset of compulsive use and significant drug related problems within two months of first use".[1] The report itself warned that these figures "represent only those who have called the" hotline, "and hence may be biased".[1]

    Methamphetamine inherited the claim. The Meth Project, which began in Montana in 2005, described itself as a prevention program "aimed at reducing first time meth use".[2][3]

    The evidence

    National surveys follow people from first use, which a hotline cannot. The National Comorbidity Survey found "an estimated 5-6% of cocaine users becoming cocaine dependent in the first year of use", or "about one in 16 to 20 cocaine users becoming dependent within the first year of cocaine use". Over a longer span, "some 15-16% of cocaine users had developed cocaine dependence within 10 years of first cocaine use".[4] A larger survey, NESARC, put the lifetime chance of dependence at "67.5% for nicotine users, 22.7% for alcohol users, 20.9% for cocaine users, and 8.9% for cannabis users".[5] Cocaine is among the riskier drugs on that list, and most users still never become dependent.

    How cocaine is taken matters, and that is the true core of the legend. A 1996 JAMA review found "greater propensity for dependence, and more severe consequences when cocaine is smoked" or injected than when it is snorted. It also found that "The physiological and psychoactive effects of cocaine are similar regardless of whether it is in the form of cocaine hydrochloride or crack cocaine", so the speed and amount of the dose count "rather than the form of the cocaine".[6]

    Even regular users keep making choices. In a 2000 laboratory study, "Six experienced cocaine smokers" were offered smoked cocaine or a $5 voucher, and "significantly less cocaine was self-administered when money vouchers were available".[7]

    Methamphetamine is the harder case to measure. A 2020 CDC report calls it "a highly addictive central nervous system stimulant", and among adults who had used it in the past year "52.9% had a methamphetamine use disorder".[8] That is a group that kept using; it leaves out people who tried it once and stopped, and even within it about half had no disorder.[8]

    The propaganda

    The Meth Project's advertising "portrays methamphetamine users as unhygienic, dangerous, untrustworthy, and exploitive", a 2008 review found, and "empirical support for the campaign is weak". The review added: "These and other negative findings have been ignored and misrepresented by the MMP".[9] An economist who measured youth meth use before and after the campaign found that, allowing for a decline already under way, "effects on meth use are statistically indistinguishable from zero".[3]

    References

    1. Report to Congress on Crack Cocaine. National Drug Enforcement Policy Board, September 1986, NCJRS digitization
    2. The Meth Project, home page. The Meth Project, Wayback capture of 6 January 2009
    3. Does information matter? The effect of the Meth Project on meth use among youths. Journal of Health Economics 29:732 (2010), via PubMed
    4. From first drug use to drug dependence; developmental periods of risk for dependence upon marijuana, cocaine, and alcohol. Neuropsychopharmacology 26:479 (2002), via PubMed
    5. Probability and predictors of transition from first use to dependence on nicotine, alcohol, cannabis, and cocaine: results of the National Epidemiologic Survey on Alcohol and Related Conditions (NESARC). Drug and Alcohol Dependence 115:120 (2011), via PubMed
    6. Crack cocaine and cocaine hydrochloride. Are the differences myth or reality?. JAMA 276:1580 (1996), via PubMed
    7. Alternative reinforcers differentially modify cocaine self-administration by humans. Behavioural Pharmacology 11:87 (2000), via PubMed
    8. Patterns and Characteristics of Methamphetamine Use Among Adults, United States, 2015-2018. MMWR 69:317 (2020), via PubMed
    9. Drugs, money, and graphic ads: a critical review of the Montana Meth Project. Prevention Science 9:256 (2008), via PubMed

Tell us something