CH₃CH₃

Urban legends

The things everybody has heard about drugs. Each one here has a verdict, the earliest appearance we can document, what the record actually says, and who spread it. A verdict of true is allowed: some of them are right.

1 legend match.

PCP

  • Misleading

    PCP gives people superhuman strength.

    PCP is an anaesthetic: it blocks pain and can cause delirium, so a person may fight on through injury. Users feel strong; no source shows they are. A review of the medical reports found its violent reputation unsupported.

    First documented: , Journal of Clinical Psychopharmacology: Brecher and colleagues call PCP's violent reputation a legacy of its spread in the late 1970s

    Origin, evidence and 6 references

    Origin

    PCP was made as a surgical anaesthetic and was "prized for its ability to provide anesthesia and analgesia" before patients' post-operative psychosis ended that use.[1] It spread as a street drug in the 1970s. By 1988 a review in the Journal of Clinical Psychopharmacology could say of that spread: "One of its legacies is the assumption that it provokes violent behavior in humans with predictable regularity".[2]

    The strength story grew out of the same reputation. A 2007 clinical review describes PCP as "sought for its ability to induce the illusion of euphoria, omnipotence, superhuman strength, and social and sexual prowess".[1] A 2004 Justice Department bulletin put it as a feeling too: "PCP users may also have feelings of strength".[3]

    The evidence

    PCP blocks pain.[1] Combined with confusion and agitation, that can look like strength: a person keeps struggling through blows or injuries that would stop anyone who felt them. The 2007 review warns that the drug's behavioural effects "combined with its analgesic effects may result in significant self-inflicted trauma", and that "most deaths in PCP intoxicated patients, however, result from patients' violent behavior rather than direct effects of the drug".[1] No source in this file measured the muscle strength of anyone on PCP, and the sources that describe the strength call it a feeling or an illusion.[1][3]

    The violence it is supposed to come with is also overstated. In 1,000 emergency department cases of PCP intoxication, "The incidence of violence was 35%", and "46% of patients were alert and oriented".[4] So most patients were not violent.

    Brecher and colleagues went further. "We reviewed 81 clinical reports of toxicity in humans", they wrote, and looked for violence that was witnessed, with PCP confirmed by a lab test and other drugs ruled out. "Of the hundreds of patients described, only three satisfied these criteria", and "some of the papers offered evidence that reports of violence were exaggerated". They concluded that "clinical and forensic assumptions about PCP and violence are not warranted".[2]

    The propaganda

    Police training still teaches the claim. A Los Angeles Police Department training bulletin from April 2023 lists among the signs of PCP use "physical strength well beyond normal capabilities", next to being "unable to feel pain".[5]

    The belief shapes how people on PCP are restrained. A study of 20 men who died after police upper-body control holds in one large city between 1974 and 1982 concluded that "control-hold use was associated with death in 19 of the 20 cases". "PCP was detected in blood or other tissues from 6 of 17 decedents tested", and the authors named PCP use as one factor to investigate.[6]

    References

    1. Phencyclidine intoxication and adverse effects: a clinical and pharmacological review of an illicit drug. California Journal of Emergency Medicine 8:9 (2007), via PubMed Central, Wayback capture
    2. Phencyclidine and violence: clinical and legal issues. Journal of Clinical Psychopharmacology 8:397 (1988), via PubMed
    3. Intelligence Bulletin: PCP Increasing Availability and Abuse. National Drug Intelligence Center, US Department of Justice, September 2004, Wayback capture
    4. Acute phencyclidine intoxication: incidence of clinical findings in 1,000 cases. Annals of Emergency Medicine 10:237 (1981), via PubMed
    5. Training Bulletin: Phencyclidine (PCP) Part I, Use of PCP. Los Angeles Police Department, vol. LII issue 5, April 2023, Wayback capture
    6. Mortality associated with the use of upper-body control holds by police. Violence and Victims 5:215 (1990), via PubMed

Tell us something